Major newspapers followed every development in the case, and the public was fascinated.
Borden’s 1893 trial, which featured considerable legal talent, expert witnesses, and forensic testimony, in some ways resembled a trial a cable television audience today would find riveting. When she was acquitted of the murders, decades of speculation began.
To this day the case is debated, and a great many people believe that Lizzie Borden got away with murder.
And in an odd twist, Lizzie Borden and the gruesome crime were kept in the public mind thanks to a rhyme that generations of American children learned on the playground.
The rhyme went as follows: "Lizzie Borden took an axe, and gave her mother 40 whacks. When she saw what she had done, she gave her father 41."
Life of Lizzie Borden
Lizzie Borden was born in 1860 to a prosperous family in Fall River, Massachusetts, the second daughter of a businessman and investor. When Lizzie was two years old her mother died, and her father, Andrew Borden, remarried.
By most accounts, Lizzie and her older sister Emma despised their father’s new wife, Abby. As the girls grew older there were many conflicts in the household, some of them rooted in the fact that Lizzie’s father, while fairly well off, was a notorious miser.
After attending public high schools, Lizzie lived at home and was involved in a number of pursuits typical for an unmarried woman who did not have to work. She was active in church groups and charitable organizations.
Despite the tensions in the Borden household which often focused on how Lizzie’s father dispensed money, Lizzie seemed sociable and quite ordinary to people in the community.
The Murder of Lizzie Borden’s Father and Stepmother
On August 4, 1892, Andrew Borden, Lizzie’s father, left the house in the morning and attended to some business. He returned home about 10:45 a.m.
Shortly after, Lizzie Borden called out to the family’s maid, “Come quick, father’s dead!”
Andrew Borden was on a couch in a parlor, the victim of a brutal attack. He had been struck numerous times, apparently with an axe or hatchet. The blows were strong enough to shatter bones and teeth, and it was obvious that he had been struck repeatedly after he was dead.
A neighbor, searching the house, discovered Borden’s wife upstairs. She had also been brutally murdered.
The Arrest of Lizzie Borden
The original suspect in the murder case was a Portugese workman with whom Andrew Borden had a business dispute. But he was cleared and attention became focused on Lizzie. She was arrested a week after the murders.
A police investigation found the head of a hatchet in the basement of the Borden house, and that was assumed to be the murder weapon. But there was also a lack of other physical evidence, such as bloodstained clothing the perpetrator of such a bloody crime must have worn.
Lizzie Borden was indicted for the two murders in December 1892, and her trial began the following June.
The Trial of Lizzie Borden
Lizzie Borden’s murder trial probably would not be terribly out of place in today’s atmosphere of tabloid headlines and cable news marathons. The trial was held in New Bedford, Massachusetts, but was covered extensively by the major newspapers in New York City.
The trial was noteworthy for the legal talent involved. One of the prosecutors, Frank Moody, later became the Attorney General of the United States and also served as a U.S. Supreme Court Justice. And Borden’s defense attorney, George Robinson, was the former governor of Massachusetts.
A Harvard professor appeared as an expert witness, an early instances of an expert witness being used in a major trial.
Borden’s lawyer succeeded in getting damaging evidence, such as the fact that she had tried to purchase poison in the weeks leading up to the murder, excluded as inadmissible. And Borden’s defense focused on the lack of physical evidence tying her to the murders.
Lizzie Borden was acquitted of murder on June 20, 1893, after the jury deliberated for less than two hours.
Later Life of Lizzie Borden
Following her trial, Borden and her sister moved into another house, where they lived for many years. Though the respectable citizens of Fall River tended to shun Lizzie and her sister, traveling actors and musicians frequented their house, leading to various rumors about the lifestyle of the sisters.
Lizzie Borden eventually died on June 1, 1927.
Legacy of the Lizzie Borden Axe Murder Case
Articles and books about the Lizzie Borden case have appeared since the early 1890s, and any number of theories have been advanced about the murders. Lizzie's father had an illegitimate son, and some believe he may have been the real culprit. And as Andrew Borden was known to be a miserly and unpopular character, it's very likely he had other enemies.
The Lizzie Borden case was a landmark in the sense that it provided a template for later tabloid stories: the case involved a very bloody crime, an unlikely defendant, rumors of family strife, and a verdict that left the question of who committed the murders unanswered.
Incidentally, the famous playground rhyme about Lizzie Borden, which apparently did not appear in print until decades after the murders, was inaccurate in several respects.
The victim, Abby Borden, was Lizzie's stepmother, not her mother. And it also greatly exaggerated the number of blows from the murder weapon. But the rhyme did keep Lizzie's name in circulation for decades after the bloody murders in Fall River.